Concursive Corporation

  • Norfolk, VA
  • 23510

Closed Minds on Open Source Security

Posted by Michael Harvey on January 11, 2008, 3:55 PM EST
Michael H. photo

There's a buzz around the internet right now regarding an article recently posted on Information Week titled "Open Source Code Contains Security Holes". If you couldn't tell from the title, this is a piece about the potential bugs in open source applications. If you couldn't guess from the title: I'm not exactly supportive of the author's standpoint.

Software inherently has bugs. It's a fact of life and I am appalled that the article makes no mention of the bug rate found in closed source software for comparison, instead hinting that open source has some fundamental problem. Bugs are found and fixed more quickly in an open source application because of the public scrutiny of the code and the community involvement in the fixing of any potential bugs.

For example: when a bug is found in software from your average Redmond-based software behemoth, nothing really happens until enough users report errors, at which point a "critical update" will be issued. One of the great aspects to open source code is that there is a community of developers keeping an eye out for any potential problems which they are keen to resolve as soon as they are discovered.

To read a recap on this topic, head over to the Enterprise Open Source blog.

I discussed this with our CTO, Tom Manos. Tom brought up the recent, and equally inaccurate, release from McAfee warning investors about the dangers of "ambiguous" open source licenses. Tom pointed out that McAfee is obviously not open source, but has similar functionality to many cheaper, or even free, open source alternatives, making its argument entirely self-serving.

I've said it before and I'll say it again. We're on the brink of a time when the towel will be thrown in for fight over open source ‘versus' closed source. The audience isn't looking for one to win over another, they just want cost-effective, feature rich applications that will help them drive their businesses.

There are no comments

Sign in to add your comment.

Recent Posts

What Constitutes an "Open" Platform
There is no rigid, hard and fast definition for what constitutes an open platform. Rather, arriving...
read more
Evaluating Trade-Offs and ROI of an Open Approach
When making important capital or strategic decisions any manager worth their salt immediately tries...
read more
Where "Open Solutions" Fit Well
The size of the organization in which a solution is being considered is usually a key determinant of...
read more
Apps for Your Health and Helping Others
In this post we're highlighting apps with a focus on health and helping others. Please check out our...
read more
Autism Village: An online social platform that helps autism families
I've been wanting to write about Autism Village for some time. The story is interesting… Topher...
read more
An Open Data story with the City of Greensboro, North Carolina – Civicon15 Hackathon
…as told by Matt Rajkowski, Chief Software Architect at Concursive. Last weekend I was able to...
read more
Be inspired with the ultimate social, local and mobile software platform
Over the years, organizations have chosen Concursive's social software to enable learning,...
read more
Behind the Scenes of a Citywide Social Community
Earlier this year SWLA Connected was launched with one of our partners. SWLA Connected is a citywide...
read more
Wow, it's 2015!
First a few product plugs… if you're not using social software in your business or organization,...
read more
The Sea Level Rise app: crowdsourcing of information
Concursive has worked with Wetlands Watch of Norfolk, Virginia to bring a new app to Apple's App...
read more

Go to blog